Unravelling the Operational Dynamics of Fact-Checking Platforms: A Comparative Analysis of PIB’s Fact Check Unit and Alt News

Abstract

The proliferation of dubious information has emerged as a global concern, particularly since the advent of social media. In response, numerous fact-checking websites have commenced efforts to counteract this widespread dissemination of misinformation. A press release generated significant attention on March 20, 2024, upon the public announcement that the Fact-Checking Unit of the Press Information Bureau (PIB) would officially be granted statutory body status. This study investigates the operational mechanisms of the Fact Check Unit (FCU), established by the Press Information Bureau, a unit of the Government of India, alongside “Alt News,” a non-profit website that operates solely on donations and grants. The research methodology employed in this study entails a comprehensive content analysis aimed at uncovering the operational dynamics involved in cross-checking and verifying facts from both websites. The study systematically evaluates the content disseminated by PIB and Alt News, focusing on the strategies employed to identify disinformation, including the types of claims that are verified, the differences in verification methods, and the transparency in reporting. Additionally, it seeks to illuminate the effectiveness and limitations of these websites.  The findings indicate that PIB predominantly concentrates on discrediting political misinformation, whereas Alt News encompasses a broader spectrum of topics. Furthermore, Alt News demonstrates greater transparency and furnishes comprehensive explanations and sources in comparison to PIB.